Fighting for Fairness Legal Action Section Link to accessible text-only version of this web site
News Updates Menu - Click and select from the menu below. Legal Action Menu - Click and select from the menu below. How to Help Menu - Click and select from the menu below. Resources Menu - Click and select from the menu below. Contact Info - Link to Contact Info Page Home - Link to Home Page

Tax Court Cases

Attorney General v. James W. Buchanan

Federal Court of Appeal upholds the ruling of the Tax Court of Canada and establishes the legal test for the tax credit for all people with mental impairments.

Top

Buchanan v. The Queen 2000

A victory for all individuals suffering from a severe and prolonged mental illness such as Bipolar Disorder.

Top

Sullivan v. The Queen 2004

The judge allows the appeal for life-sustaining therapy for 6-year-old Amanda who has Type 1 diabetes. He ruled that all of the activities carried out by her parents to keep her alive such as the monitoring the glucose levels, determining the carbohydrate requirments and the dosage of insulin in addition to injecting the insulin are interpreted as "therapy" by the Court.

Top

Albertin v. Canada 1996 -Submission - Appendix 10

Although Mrs. Rybotycka was mentally impaired only 50% of the time, the Judge ruled, "the impairment is continuous... and markedly restricts her ability to perceive, think and remember, even during periods of lucidity."

Top

Austin v. The Queen 2001

Judge allows tax credit for 14-year-old Jessica who has a severe learning disability and is not able to use the bus system on her own.

Top

Nesbitt v. The Queen 2003

Judge rules that the questionnaires sent to doctors for medical clarification cannot be used to deny the DTC because the questions are not conditions set out in the Income Tax Act.

Top

Peggy Doe v. The Queen 2003

In his testimony, Dr. Blake Woodside, president of the Canadian Psychiatric Association criticizes the T2201 form because it contains no established criteria for mental impairments. The judge rules that Ms. Doe qualifies for the DTC because the unpredictability and frequency of her epileptic seizures seriously affected her ability to perform basic activities of daily living such as perceiving, thinking and remembering.

Top

News | Court Cases | Action Alert | Appeals | Contact Info | Home
Submissions | Hearings
© 2002 Communication Resources All Rights Reserved
A Business Card Web Site™ donated by ReVision Internet Services Inc.